Discredited IPCC Also Reveals Media’s Malpractice

by Paul Chesser, Heartland Institute Correspondent on January 26, 2010

in Blog

At his BBC blog Andrew Neil lays out the itemized fraud from the 2007 UN IPCC report that has been rolling out in recent days, previously reported by the BBC and other formerly mainstream media as “sound” and “consensus” science. So many “Gates,” and so many discredited reporters:

But the flood gates really opened after the IPCC had to withdraw its claim that the Himalayan glaciers would likely all have melted by 2035, maybe even sooner.

This turned out to have no basis in scientific fact, even though everything the IPCC produces is meant to be rigorously peer-reviewed, but simply an error recycled by the [World Wildlife Fund], which the IPCC swallowed whole….

Then at the weekend another howler was exposed. The IPCC 2007 report claimed that global warming was leading to an increase in extreme weather, such as hurricanes and floods. Like its claims about the glaciers, this was also based on an unpublished report which had not been subject to scientific scrutiny — indeed several experts warned the IPCC not to rely on it.

Now after Climate-gate, Glacier-gate and Hurricane-gate — how many “gates” can one report contain? — comes Amazon-gate. The IPCC claimed that up to 40 percent of the Amazonian forests were risk from global warming and would likely be replaced by “tropical savannas” if temperatures continued to rise.

This claim is backed up by a scientific-looking reference but on closer investigation turns out to be yet another non-peer reviewed piece of work from the WWF. Indeed the two authors are not even scientists or specialists on the Amazon: one is an Australian policy analyst, the other a freelance journalist for the Guardian and a green activist.

Yep, this is the “scientific consensus” that Al Gore based his post-VP life upon; the imagined groundswell that so many politicians used to justify government growth; the nonexistent evidence that journalists cited to justify their alarmism activism. It’s the two words that every global warmist (whether lying or deceived themselves) threw in the face of skeptics in an attempt to intimidate. Didn’t work!

No wonder why hardly any of them wanted to debate and those who did got slaughtered. We tried to explain that the “consensus” was an illusion. You — yes, I’m talking about you, Society of Environmental Journalists — would have none of it.

Now you’re stuck in the shoes of the environmental equivalent of Jayson Blair as your newspapers and television stations fall apart, and while what’s left of your audience doesn’t care about the issue you hold so precious. But it’s your good fortune that you still qualify for the do-nothing flack positions that are plentiful in both government and nonprofit arms of the environoia industry.

Mr. Xyz January 26, 2010 at 4:16 pm


A relatively tame Hitler parody video

"As chief operating officer for the cabal of Billionaires who control the global warming scam, Hitler quickly realizes the long range implications of "Glaciergate"."

Glaciergate: Hitler's Last Straw


Bob R Geologist, Tuc January 29, 2010 at 10:13 pm

Reasoning from known paleoclimatology, I would much prefer the made from whole cloth hypothesis of AGW. Climate history really tells us that even at times when CO2 has reached 10 times or more the amount in our present atmosphere, there has been no extinction events due to excessive heat. It was much warmer thruout the age of the dinosaurs and life thrived and evolved. Dinosaurs were known by their fossils in the Arctic and Antartic. 50 my ago world temperatures began declining, thought due to plate tectonic changes to geography that ended an equitorial warm ocean current that had branches poleward N & S. About 14 my ago ice began forming at our poles. Only 1 3/4 my ago The Pleistocene ice ages began. N. America has had 5 ice ages of at least 100,000 years duration separated by varying interglacial periods. No one can say that our present inter-glacial stage (Holocene) that we have been in the last 12,000 years is permanent. However our average temperature is several deg C below the era of the dinosaurs and remains in a glacial mode as long as ice remains at our poles. It is my belief that it is pure folly to think we are out of the ice for keeps. The Holocene has been normal with at least 4 warm periods of at least a thousand years duration separated by similar length cooler periods. We have been recovering from the Little Ice Age since around 1300 AD, a time of diminished magnetic activity (little sunspot action). Our global temperature has actually declined a fractional deg C during the past 10 years when the hype has become strident that never has our temperature increased so rapidly! Perhaps the biggest "whopper" of all time.

pojoe February 4, 2010 at 9:13 am

HITLERS LAST STRAW hitler had a lot off key player in his government on of them was Joseph Gerbols do you remember what he did in hitlers government well we have two propaganda ministers BIG OIL AND COAL who dont want use to ever want use stop using there products

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: