In a joint letter yesterday, more than 100 scientists, including Kerry Emmanuel (MIT), James Hansen (Columbia University), and Michael Mann (Penn State University), urged American Geophysical Union (AGU) President Margaret Leinen to “reconsider” (i.e. terminate) ExxonMobil’s sponsorship of the association’s Fall meetings. Climatewire ($) provides some useful context:
AGU’s meeting is the largest earth science conference in the world. It attracts tens of thousands of scientists and requires a conference space so large that it is used by Apple Inc. and Google Inc. for their yearly developer meetings. There are hundreds of sessions on the science of climate change. Exxon Mobil is a prominent sponsor and recruiter at the meeting and paid AGU $35,000 last year.
Leinen declined to give ExxonMobil the boot. As explained yesterday on her blog (h/t Anthony Watts), AGU’s Board discussed allegations that ExxonMobil is promoting “misinformation about climate change, climate science and the role of human activity in climate change, or actively supporting organizations that do,” and concluded that “ExxonMobil’s current public statements and activities were not inconsistent with AGU’s positions and the scientific consensus.” However, expulsion remains an option if, in the future, the company deviates from AGU’s positions:
As the leaders of AGU, we welcome questions and requests from our members and others in the scientific community, and we assure you that if verifiable information becomes available that proves ExxonMobil is currently engaging in the promotion of misinformation about science or adopting positions that are in conflict with AGU’s own, or supporting groups that do, we will end the relationship, as dictated by our policy–at least until the company is able to demonstrate that such actions have ceased.
Hardly a profile in courage. Indeed, Leinem and the Exxon bashers tacitly agree that AGU’s role is not to facilitate debate of competing scientific viewpoints but to define and enforce a party line. [click to continue…]